Turn this comparison into procurement-ready diligence
Free shows today's risk. A Stack Audit gives you a citable, verbatim-sourced PDF across your whole AI stack — and flags the moment a vendor's terms change.
SIDE-BY-SIDE · 2 OF 3
Two platforms.
Same questions.
SAP Joule
WORKFLOW & AUTOMATION
PROMPT
Users retain full ownership of submitted prompt characters and keywords.
OUTPUT
Outputs are assigned fully to users under standard commercial parameters.
TRAINING
Data is kept secure within tenant spaces. Model training on enterprise work boards is contractually excluded.
COMMERCIAL
Commercial use of all workflow priorities and prioritizations is fully permitted.
412 verified findings across the displayed surfaces.
Spellbook
ENTERPRISE SEARCH / PRODUCTIVITY
PROMPT
Law firm customers own all contract documents and legal inputs. Spellbook (Rally Legal) processes documents for AI contract review and drafting.
OUTPUT
Customers own all AI-generated contract language, suggestions, and redlines. Spellbook does not assert IP over outputs.
TRAINING
Unknown — cached spellbook-ai_tos.txt contains policy text in a single HTML line (line 362) exceeding the 25,000-token Read tool limit. Core IP and data use sections (1–12) are inaccessible. Sections 13.7–13.13 (dispute resolution, governing law: New York) were readable. Privacy file has same structure issue.
COMMERCIAL
Commercial use is fully permitted for legal practice and enterprise contract management.
177 verified findings across the displayed surfaces.
Empty Comparison Slot
AIRIN SUMMARY
SAP Joule has moderate defaults; Spellbook carries the most permissive license terms of the set.FOR ENTERPRISE: SAP JOULE ENTERPRISE TIER ACCEPTABLE · SPELLBOOK NOT RECOMMENDED
↳ Compliance surfaces · side by side
⚡ INTERACTIVE RISK COMPARISON HEATMAP
| RISK SURFACE | SAP JOULE | SPELLBOOK |
|---|---|---|
| PPrompt Ownership | ||
| OOutput Ownership | ||
| TModel Training | ||
| CCommercial Use | ||
| DData Privacy | ||
| $Tier Differences |
* Click any cell in the heatmap matrix to scroll directly to its verbatim policy citations below.
📂 Intellectual Property & Model Training
P
SURFACE 01
Prompt Ownership
SAP Joule
HIGHMED
Users retain full ownership of submitted prompt characters and keywords.
“ SAP does not claim ownership of User Content that you post, upload, input, or submit to any SAP Website. By posting, transmitting, or uploading any User Content, including, but not limited to, any article, information, data, code, text, software, documentation, graphic, image, m…”
Spellbook
MED⚠ CAUTIONHIGH
Law firm customers own all contract documents and legal inputs. Spellbook (Rally Legal) processes documents for AI contract review and drafting.
“ (b) This Agreement does not grant Customer any intellectual property license or rights in or to the Spellbook AI Platform or any of its components, except to the limited extent that such rights are necessary for Customer's use of the Spellbook AI Platform as specifically au…”
O
SURFACE 02
Output Ownership
SAP Joule
MEDMED
Outputs are assigned fully to users under standard commercial parameters.
“ The AI Functionality are designed to provide information, assistance, and other forms of useful output. However, SAP does not guarantee the accuracy, completeness, or reliability of any information or content generated by the AI Functionality. You are advised to independently ve…”
Spellbook
MEDHIGH
Customers own all AI-generated contract language, suggestions, and redlines. Spellbook does not assert IP over outputs.
“ 6.2. Feedback. ”
T
SURFACE 03
Model Training
SAP Joule
HIGHMED
Data is kept secure within tenant spaces. Model training on enterprise work boards is contractually excluded.
“ Products and services : This may include any of SAP’s on-premise and cloud software products, web services, apps, online-forums, webinars and events, non-marketing related newsletters, white papers, tutorials, trainings, as well as other offerings like contests or sweepstakes. W…”
Spellbook
MED⚠ CAUTIONHIGH
Unknown — cached spellbook-ai_tos.txt contains policy text in a single HTML line (line 362) exceeding the 25,000-token Read tool limit. Core IP and data use sections (1–12) are inaccessible. Sections 13.7–13.13 (dispute resolution, governing law: New York) were readable. Privacy file has same structure issue.
“ (iv) No Third Party LLM Model Training. Customer Data transmitted to Third Party LLMs via the Spellbook AI Platform will not be used to train, improve, or develop the AI models of those Third Party LLMs. Accordingly, Spellbook will ensure that all Third Party LLMs are prohibited…”
C
SURFACE 04
Commercial Use
SAP Joule
MED⚠ CAUTIONMED
Commercial use of all workflow priorities and prioritizations is fully permitted.
“ To comply with data protection and unfair competition law related requirements. Depending on the country in which the relevant SAP Group member operates, and whether you have expressly consented to or opted out of receiving commercial information, SAP may process personal data n…”
Spellbook
MED⚠ CAUTIONHIGH
Commercial use is fully permitted for legal practice and enterprise contract management.
“ (i) reverse engineer, decompile, disassemble, or otherwise attempt to derive the source code or underlying algorithms of the Spellbook AI Platform;”
📂 Data Privacy & Governance
D
SURFACE 05
Data Privacy
SAP Joule
MEDMED
—
“ If you want to learn more about each of these purposes for which SAP may collect, transfer, and use your personal data, including for how long your data is being retained and specific to the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) , the legal ground on which SAP is pursuing…”
Spellbook
MED⚠ CAUTIONHIGH
—
“ (a) Spellbook collects and uses categories of Personal Data from the Customer and its Users that are required to administer Customer's Spellbook account, including payment records and credit cards. Otherwise, Spellbook only collects and uses Personal Data as necessary to pr…”
$
SURFACE 06
Tier Differences
SAP Joule
MED
—
No citation available
Spellbook
MED⚠ CAUTIONHIGH
—
“ (b) Spellbook reserves the right to discontinue or modify its provision of any Beta Features to the Customer at any time, with or without notice;”